There has long been controversy brewing about site measurement. This time, a NY Times piece titled “How Many Site Hits? Depends Who’s Counting” is tackling the issue. Advertisers want to keep their budgets down and publishers wish to benefit from having accurate circulation counts.
One aspect of the debate is critical to me:
Both comScore and NetRatings are cooperating with audits by the Media Rating Council, a nonprofit organization that has approved ratings systems since the 1960s. Among other issues, the council is investigating whether the companies’ panels actually represent all Web users.
In my eyes, the actual makeup of panels from comScore or Nielsen/NetRatings needs to reflect the makeup of the internet population being monitored. I’ve never met a single person who is tracked by either company. I suspect that our core demographic of 18-35s are underrepresented as well.
I will only know for sure when Fixion Media ponies up tens of thousands for such measurement. We can only hope it’s more profitable than self-reporting traffic data.